Our response to COVID19

The QA Commons is mindful of the dramatic and transformational impact COVID-19 is having on all institutions of higher education. As an organization, we are adapting our services to support preparing graduates for the workplace that is now changing more precipitously than ever.

« BACK TO NEWS

Which fork do I use?

What Continuation Students Taught Us About Navigating Opportunity

In Titanic, Jack Dawson sits down to a first-class dinner, stares at the silverware, and gets a whispered tip from Molly Brown: start from the outside and work your way in. In Pretty Woman, a hotel manager walks Vivian through the place setting the night before her big dinner. The person who doesn’t know which fork to use has become one of the most worn-out images we have for class and the unwritten rules of professional life. We’d have happily avoided it.

Then, partway through a business lunch in the rural town of Calistoga, CA a continuation high school student asked us which fork to use.

Clichés usually get that way by being true. Nobody’s career has turned on salad forks, and the fork itself was never the point. The question underneath it was: Do I know how to operate here? Can I see myself in a place like this? Over two years of working with continuation students in Napa County, we heard that question in many forms. How do I introduce myself to someone I don’t know? What am I supposed to ask an employer? What does a supervisor mean by “take initiative”?

Much of this is never explicitly taught in school. Most people who know it picked it up at the dinner table, from a parent’s colleague, at a summer job someone helped arrange. None of it appears on a transcript, and it does a lot to decide who moves comfortably through workplaces and who doesn’t.

With support from the Roger Trinchero Family Foundation, QA Commons spent two years at Palisades Continuation High School in Calistoga and one year at Valley Oak High School in Napa. Palisades is tiny, usually seven or eight students at a time, all identified as socioeconomically disadvantaged. Valley Oak serves 134. By the state’s 2025 measures, 95 percent of Valley Oak students were not prepared for college or career.

That number is accurate. It’s also incomplete. In the small Palisades cohort, students who seemed checked out during worksheets came alive when the format changed. A couple gave oral presentations strong enough to suggest a future in sales. One had an extraordinary command of geography. Another took charge when the group made a wrong turn on a field trip and worked out how to get everyone where they were going. Another was the teammate everyone could count on to follow through.

None of that shows up in test scores. For most teenagers, school is the main measure of whether they’re any good, and continuation students have, almost by definition, struggled with it. It isn’t surprising that many arrived with a thin sense of what they could do. Part of the work became helping them see capabilities they already had, and find words for those capabilities that would mean something to an employer.

It would be easy to call this an information problem. Mostly, it isn’t. These students know that jobs exist, that community college exists, that electricians and nurses and winemakers exist. What’s harder to see from the outside is how opportunity works: what a workplace feels like, how professionals talk to each other, how people actually get into a field, whom you’re allowed to ask for help, how one opportunity leads to the next.

Students from professional families absorb most of this without anyone deciding to teach it. Sociologists have described the pattern for decades, from Pierre Bourdieu’s work on cultural capital to Mark Granovetter’s “strength of weak ties” to Raj Chetty’s more recent finding that cross-class social connections are strongly associated with upward mobility. Many continuation students have had fewer chances to pick it up.

So we spent a lot of time outside the classroom. The Fire Chief in the nearby city of St. Helena gave up an entire day to ride with students in a city van, stopping at the water treatment plant, the wastewater plant, City Hall, public works, and the fire station. At Castello di Amorosa, students were captivated by the castle’s history, particularly the artwork on its walls and the stories behind it. The Vice President of Hospitality and Events built on that experience, turning what could have been a routine discussion of jobs in the wine industry into an engaging conversation about hospitality, leadership, and workplace culture. At Napa Valley College, students toured the welding and winemaking programs, ate lunch in the student commons, and met staff whose backgrounds looked a lot like their own.

What stood out was how students changed over repeated visits. They got more comfortable introducing themselves, asking questions, and walking into rooms that at first seemed to belong to someone else. Some of the experiences that seemed to matter most (business lunches, coffee with professionals, an afternoon of tennis with the Mayor of Calistoga) weren’t designed to teach a discrete skill at all. They gave students practice being in places that had looked, from a distance, like they were “not for people like me.”

We can’t claim those experiences caused anything. This was practice-based work, not a controlled study. But we saw the same pattern across enough students and enough settings to think that belonging deserves a place next to skills in how we talk about employability.

Experience opened the door, but it didn’t do the work by itself. A field trip can easily become one more activity completed. What turned it into learning was the conversation afterward: What surprised you? What did you do well? What would you do differently? What does this tell you about work, or about yourself?

Valley Oak’s first paid internship program made this especially clear. Twenty-four students spent five weeks, about six hours a week, working in district transportation, food services, and maintenance, plus one private business. At the end, each gave a presentation. They weren’t asked to list tasks. They were asked what employability qualities they had built, what surprised them, and how the experience had changed their thinking about what comes next. Supervisors came to those presentations, and guests kept remarking on how reflective and mature the students were. More than one supervisor said they wished they’d had something like it in high school.

Reflection is also an employability skill in its own right, though schools rarely name it that way. Workers have to judge their own performance, take feedback, notice what went wrong, and carry a lesson from one situation into the next.

Resumes taught us something similar. Students often started with phrases like “hard worker” or “good with people.” The real work was helping them find evidence in a paid job, family work, volunteering, or responsibilities at home, and then revising until the evidence was clear. The learning was in the revision. One student reacted sharply to a set of written edits made without a conversation first, saying the reviewer didn’t know them. It was a fair point. Feedback that arrives without a relationship reads as judgment.

There’s a tension here worth sitting with. Schools are built to count completion: credits earned, assignments submitted, a resume in the folder. Employability asks for something closer to judgment, quality, and the ability to improve without someone correcting every line. A student can finish the resume assignment and still not know how to represent what they can do.

The most uncomfortable finding may be about timing.

Students are routinely told to figure out what they want to do after high school. For many continuation students, that question lands while they’re recovering credits, working, helping support family, and worrying about rent. One student wrote that if they didn’t succeed, “the system will just forget about us.” What adults offer as an invitation to explore can feel like pressure to make a high-stakes decision without enough information to make it well.

Much of what we’d most want students to understand (how advancement works, when a credential pays off, what a supervisor’s feedback really means, when to stay in a job and when to leave) doesn’t fully make sense until they’re in it. Giving a student a detailed career map before graduation is a bit like handing someone a trail map before a hard hike. It helps, but most of it won’t click until they’re standing on the mountain trying to decide which way to go.

And that’s exactly when support disappears. Before graduation, students have teachers, counselors, and adults asking about their plans. A year later, when they’re in a first job and the questions get real, most of that structure is gone.

The local labor market raises the stakes on those later decisions. In Napa County, roughly 40 percent of jobs require a high school diploma or equivalent, and about a quarter need no formal education beyond employer training. That’s encouraging for students who aren’t headed straight to a four-year college. But the easiest jobs to get aren’t the ones that pay best. Food service, personal care, healthcare support, and farming jobs generally pay under $20 an hour, in an extremely expensive place to live. Production, construction, maintenance, and repair tend to pay more, often with training well short of a bachelor’s degree. A first job can be a foothold. Whether it becomes a path depends on knowing what comes next and how to get there.

There are early hints of what might be possible. Of the six students who graduated from the Palisades cohort, three were enrolled in or preparing to start college by August 2026, two of them living in the Napa Valley College residence halls. Their teacher, who has stayed in touch with graduates over many years, called that unusual for the program. Six students are far too few to draw conclusions from, and we can’t say what role the project played. It’s still worth paying attention to.

If there’s one lesson running through all of this, it’s that employability doesn’t live in any single activity. A resume workshop, an internship, a badge, a field trip: each helps, and none is sufficient. The learning happens where those experiences meet relationships, feedback, reflection, and a growing sense of how opportunity works.

Much of that doesn’t require a new course. At Valley Oak, most of the work fit into existing advisory periods: a professional email critiqued by a classmate, a one-minute talk about an industry video, a text to a family member or coach asking, “What am I good at?” Plenty of these skills are already being practiced in ordinary classes. A group project is teamwork. Revising an essay after feedback is adaptability. The missing step is usually naming it, so students recognize what they’re practicing and can describe it to someone outside school.

The harder implication concerns when support ends. If career learning becomes most real in the first year or two after graduation, then a model that stops at the graduation stage stops just as the lessons start to matter. We don’t yet know what light-touch support for recent continuation graduates should look like, who should provide it, or how to pay for it. That seems like the right question to work on next.

The student who asked about the fork had plenty of ambition and plenty of talent. What they wanted to know was how the room worked. Most of us learned that so early we’ve forgotten someone had to teach it.

 

Follow our work

Enter your email below to follow this project and receive notifications.

Thank You!

We appreciate you contacting us. One of our colleagues will get back to you shortly.

gototop